Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages

My fiance and I stayed here at Andrew's Inn for our 5 year anniversary. From the cleanliness of the room to the accommodations, happy hour and delicious breakfast served every morning, we were right at home. We walked to Duval street almost every day we were there. We also got to hear the Hemingway Tour right from our balcony. This hidden gem is an untapped resource. And we definitely will be going back. Thank you to the staff for keeping this place as tidy as it was. And for being friendly and making us feel as comfortable as possible while staying with you. Ryan and Nina Sheehan

We absolutely loved our stay at Andrews Inn & Cottages! The property feels wonderfully secluded and peaceful, tucked away yet right in the heart of Key West. The atmosphere was quiet and relaxing, with a charming, small pool that became the perfect spot to unwind after exploring. The location couldn’t be better — close to everything but still private and calm. What really stood out, though, was the staff. Everyone was amazing: friendly, attentive, and welcoming. Isabella, in particular, went above and beyond to make our stay feel special. If you’re looking for a hidden gem in Key West with great amenities and even better people, this is it. I met a couple that had be coming there for fifteen years and I completely understand why. P.S. If you’re looking for a place to be loud with friends late at night, keep looking.

Very small,private,and very kind owners. Room was super clean and nice. Swimming pool was great for do a quick jump. And also happy hours was fantastic. Even on first day when we came after 4:00pm. We also pay parking,but it’s worth,is on entrance to hotel.

We originally found out about Andrews Inn on Reddit, from some locals and former guests. This Inn and the staff far exceeded our expectations. Located literally in the backyard of the Ernest Heminway home this beautiful property is a Key West dream. Imagine our surprise when we looked over our porch to see the tour, we were a part of, just over Heminway's hand laid brick wall. In fact, we were visited quite often by own friendly 6toe kitty from next door! Our space was the Roma cottage. The room was pristine, well appointed, and absolutely cozy. A Nectar mattress nestled in a four-poster bed; nice cold ac and premium sheets made for a great post-Duval nap and the authentic Key West porch was the real Chef's kiss. The pool area was insane. When its 99 degrees and 80% humidity, this private lush tropical pool alone is worth every dime. We could hear all commotion from Duval and my wife commented several times how fantastic this lil garden heaven was to escape the madness. The best part is the small boutique feel of the Inn. You really feel like it could be your home with a few friends. Don't skip the full breakfast including charcuterie and 24 hr coffee. Bikes are included so you can just zip down to the Southernmost point (5 mins away) or Mallory square for sunset. Izabella, the manager, was amazing. We visited as a part of a "make a wish-bucket list) stay for my wife. Izabella and the staff at AIC made it so nice she shed a tear having to leave. I personally want to thank the staff and owners for being great people in a sometimes not so great world. This weekend will live forever in our minds. GORGEOUS PEACEFUL COZY ESCAPE

A beautiful special place. Delightful staff in a unique relaxing setting. Lively rooms..beds..super breakfast and a lovely 2 hour happy hour.

Beautiful place right off Duval , feels like a little oasis yet very close to everything. Continental breakfast is very good, besides the usual includes eggs, bacon or sausage , waffles or French toast. Happy hour is included and a great way to meet other guests We only stay here!