The pepperoni slice with ricotta was huge. Seriously, I couldn&#39;t finish it in one go and had the rest for lunch the next day. For the price, that&#39;s a solid deal in NYC.

Been coming here for years, and the service is always solid. Last Friday was crazy busy, but our server was still on top of things. Food came out hot and tasted just right, like it always does. That&#39;s why I keep coming back.

Stopped in for a quick bite. The turkey sandwich was decent, fresh and simple. The quiche was pretty good too. The place itself is cute, though a bit small. A nice little spot.

Came for a date night. Cozy, elegant spot. The wine list is on the pricier side, but we found some really nice choices. Lively atmosphere was perfect.

Outdoor seating is the move. Quieter than inside. Had the chicken sandwich there. Solid. Fries were crispy.

Been back for the salmon bow tie pasta a few times. It&#39;s reliable, tastes good every visit. Service is always friendly and efficient. Solid choice for a quick business lunch near the office.

Reighn was super friendly and attentive, checked in just the right amount. The positive vibe really made the evening feel relaxed.

The ceviche de camaron here is fantastic. Fresh shrimp, just the right amount of lime, and the texture was spot on. I&#39;d come back for that alone. The staff was really nice, too.

Been coming here for years, it&#39;s the real deal. Got the mixed platter last night, always a good choice. The beftekia was spot on, gyro was solid too. Washed it down with a cold Fix.

Been coming here for years. The servers are always on point, and they know the menu inside out.

The Boston cream donut is my go-to here. It&#39;s simple, fresh, and not overly sweet. The filling has a nice texture, and the chocolate on top isn&#39;t waxy. The others are good, but this one is the standout.

The bacon salad was fantastic, really hit the spot. It&#39;s a classic steakhouse vibe, and the front-of-house staff clearly know what they&#39;re doing. Just a solid, comfortable spot.

Service was on point. The breakfast platter was huge and tasty, hit the spot. Might swing by for dinner next time.

The staff was so considerate. They called ahead when it looked like rain and moved our outdoor table inside without any fuss. Our server also suggested a lovely wine that didn&rsquo;t break the bank. Made for a very relaxed evening.

Planning a Islip trip? Discover the best restaurants in Islip with traveller reviews, ratings, menus, photos and exclusive dining deals. Book tables instantly on Trip.com.

The best restaurants in Islip

Angela's Pizzeria

Buseto Pizza

Da Noi Italian Restaurant

Manhattan Sweets Boutique Bkry

Maxwell's

Mediterranean Express - Powered by The Greek

Bubba's Burrito Bar

Tellers: An American Chophouse

Oconee Diner

McDonald's

The Pizzeria of Islip

Savor Eatery

Maple Street Deli

Mango Tango

Bo Wah Kitchen

Harp & Hound

Bagels & More

Corner Galley

Aux Délices Foods by Debra Ponzek

Columbus Park Trattoria

Barcelona Wine Bar

Capriccio Kitchen & Bar

IHOP

Don Carmelo's Mexican Grill & Tequila Bar

Pontos Taverna

bartaco

Coffee An' Donut Shop

Joseph's Steakhouse

RACHEL’S Restaurant & Bakery

Grotta di Fuoco