New Shoreham Food Guide: Best Restaurants in New Shoreham

83. Domino's Pizza

4/5

1 Reviews

Western-style

New_York_GossipWe drove over using the GPS and realized the Domino's Pizza location was wrong. It's actually between a Shell and Hess gas station. I recommend following the directions on Google Maps. We ordered three items, but they only gave us two. If we hadn't noticed, they wouldn't have given us the complimentary chicken wing dipping sauce. It felt like the staff were being careless. The food was average. I preferred the wings and the thin crust pizza. Their sandwiches and pasta dishes are also good.

87. Sushi Kawa

5/5

1 Reviews

New_York_GossipThe restaurant has plenty of parking spaces, and it was very convenient for us to park when we drove here. The service of the waiter was very good. The restaurant mainly serves Japanese dishes, including sushi, grill, rice, noodles, tempura, etc. There are many sushi sets to choose from.

89. Showfish

No comments yet

Seafood

palettes_ny#Show you my travel guide 💥Showfish 📍32 Star Island Rd, Montauk, NY 11954 🕙Monday to Sunday 7:00-11:00; 12:00-15:30; 17:30-22:00 💰Lunch is $35 per person, dinner is $70 per person You need to go to the town to find restaurants around the hotel, so I had lunch and dinner with my friends at the restaurant in the hotel. I didn't have high hopes for the restaurant in the hotel, but I was surprised after eating there. I felt that lunch would be better than dinner. Moreover, the restaurant's outdoor area faces the sea directly, so you can watch the sunset during dinner. The dining environment is very romantic. ✨Tuna Tartare✨ Their tuna tartare is amazing after one bite. It is a very suitable appetizer for a sunny afternoon. It tastes very refreshing. ✨Roasted Turkey✨ The roasted turkey sandwich is very juicy and not dry at all. The bread is also baked crispy. ✨Charred Octopus✨ The overall feeling of dinner is not as amazing as lunch. Although the appetizer octopus legs are small in size, the seasoning is still good. ✨Day Boat Scallops✨ It feels like a main course of an appetizer. There are four scallops in one serving. It is delicious, but it is true that you are not full. ✨Tagliatelle✨ Lobster pasta is a main course that is very filling compared to scallops, but the taste is light. The lobster meat is very fresh and chewy.

Best Restaurants in August in New Shoreham (Updated 2025)

82. Johnny Rockets

83. Domino's Pizza

84. The Beach Club at Gurney's Montauk

85. Ocean Beach Park

86. Coastal Crepes

87. Sushi Kawa

88. Irish American Athletic Club

89. Showfish