The salads and paninis are solid, but I really like the vibe here. It&#39;s a nice, relaxed spot.

The pollo especial was so fresh and flavorful. The black beans were a perfect healthy side.

Sharing the building with a brewery upstairs is a cool setup. Gives the place a nice local vibe. The beer selection is great, had a couple with my burger.

The wine list here is solid. Found a new favorite red, a Spanish Tempranillo that had this nice earthy note. Good price for the quality. The food looks pretty, but honestly, I&#39;m just here for the wine.

The food tastes fresh, not like typical chain restaurant fare. The seating is comfortable, which made the meal relaxing.

The latte here was just what I needed after walking all day. It was really smooth and not too sweet. A great spot to grab a drink and catch up with a friend.

Been coming here for years after hiking. The portions are always huge, and the food tastes just like I remember it. That&#39;s why I keep coming back.

Cozy spot with dim lighting, perfect for a chill dinner with friends. The staff remembered my friend&#39;s gluten-free request without us even asking! Steak was cooked just right.

Stopped in for breakfast. Felt like a small-town diner, real homemade vibe. Staff was super friendly. Pancakes were fluffy, eggs just right. Coffee kept coming. Nice spot to start the day.

The meatloaf was really good. The place has a nice country vibe with horse pictures everywhere.

Service is super fast and they remember your order without writing it down. Makes a quick lunch feel more personal.

Been coming here for years. The wagyu steak is always spot on, cooked just right. Duck confit is a solid choice too. Wine list is good, they know their stuff. It&#39;s not cheap, but you get what you pay for.

I&#39;ve been to their Harry Potter and Paris tea events. The themed menus and decor are cute, but honestly, the price for the portion of food you get feels a bit steep. It&#39;s a fun outing, just wish there was a little more on the plate for what you pay.

Been coming here for years. Jacob and Emily always remember my usual order. Food&#39;s consistently hot when it hits the table, which I really appreciate. That&#39;s the main reason I keep coming back.

Solid spot for a quick lunch. Grabbed an everything bagel with lox. Tasted just like the ones back in NYC. Got it to go and was out the door in under 10 minutes. Perfect for when you&#39;re in a rush.

The outdoor patio is so spacious, perfect for a warm night. I tried their lavender lemonade&mdash;really refreshing and not too sweet. Just a nice spot to hang out.

Got the bangers and mash special. Honestly, one of the best things I&#39;ve had in a while. The sausage was perfectly seasoned and the mash was so creamy. Even though the place was packed for the festival, service was quick and our drinks stayed full.

The crab cakes are fantastic. Love the rustic pub vibe and the pool table in the corner.

Sat at the bar for a casual lunch. Bartender was on point with service. Shared the wings and the 50/50 salad&mdash;the greens were surprisingly fresh. Their house red by the glass was a solid, easy-drinking choice that went well with both.

The garlic knots were so warm and buttery. Just the right amount of garlic, and the sauce was really fresh.

Cozy little spot. The outdoor seating is nice when the weather&#39;s decent. Service was quick and friendly, as usual. The pasta was pretty good, though the portion felt a bit small for the price. A solid choice for a casual lunch.

Chicken parm and the pork chop were both really good. Nice spot for a family dinner.

The cocktails were the real star for me. So well-balanced, not too sweet. The food was thoughtful too, but those drinks... they just hit the spot.

The Springhouse cottage was a nice stay. It was quiet and cozy, and the screened-in porch was a great feature. Everything was fine, though the decor felt a bit dated.

The lunch specials are a steal, super filling for the price. But the real star for me was the bar area &ndash; the lighting is just right, not too bright, and the stools are actually comfortable. A nice spot to unwind.

Greek omelet with feta was a solid choice. Good, fluffy eggs and the feta wasn&#39;t too salty. Nice spot for a late breakfast.

Bartender was on it before we even sat down. Solid happy hour, good place to catch a game. Drinks were well-made, service was quick.

Love the vibe of this converted gas station. The crab cake was packed with lump meat, not too much filler. Fried chicken thighs were crispy outside, juicy inside. Cheeseburger was solid too. Everything just tasted fresh and well-made.

Your ultimate guide to dining in Middletown. Discover top-rated restaurants and local favorites, based on authentic traveler ratings and reviews. ▸ See menus & photos ▸ Find hidden gems ▸ Plan your perfect trip.

The best restaurants in Middletown

Café del Sol

El Centro

Roma Old Town Wood-Fired Pizzeria

Violino Ristorante Italiano

Houlihan's

Gathering Grounds Patisserie & Cafe

Osteria Maria

Element

L'Dees Pancake House

Main Street Mill Restaurant

Melting Pot Pizza

The Ashby Inn & Restaurant

The Tea Cart

Hunter's Head Tavern

Sclafani's New York Bagels and Bread

Piccadilly's Public House & Restaurant

Union Jack Pub & Restaurant

Cork Street Tavern

50/50 Taphouse

Il Vesuvio Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Best Thai Kitchen

Oak Stone Craft Pizza and Bar

King Street Oyster Bar Middleburg

The Inn at Lost River

Roma Casual Italian & Greek Dining

Camino Real Mexican Restaurant

Santorini Grill

Glory Days Grill

Bonnie Blue Southern Market & Bakery

Ledo Pizza