With a stay at The Tama Hotel in Krabi (Ao Nang), you'll be a 1-minute drive from Ao Nam Mao and 15 minutes from Krabi Hospital. This hotel is 4.8 mi (7.8 km) from Nopparat Thara Beach and 11.1 mi (17.8 km) from Tesco Lotus Krabi.
Take advantage of recreation opportunities such as an outdoor pool, or other amenities including wireless internet access (surcharge) and tour/ticket assistance.
Featured amenities include wired internet access (surcharge), a 24-hour front desk, and multilingual staff. Self parking (subject to charges) is available onsite.
Make yourself at home in one of the 40 air-conditioned rooms featuring flat-screen televisions. Complimentary wireless internet access keeps you connected, and satellite programming is available for your entertainment. Bathrooms feature showers with rainfall showerheads. Conveniences include desks and complimentary bottled water, and housekeeping is provided daily.
GGuest User2025.11.19
The room was spacious, featuring a balcony and a bathroom with a dry/wet separation, and the hot water supply was excellent. The only downside was the slightly old mattress, which lacked support on the edges. All the staff were very friendly and cheerful; they even gave me a cake for my birthday (as I was staying for an extended period). The hotel is located in Ao Nam Mao, and it costs around 100 baht to get to Ao Nang Beach by taxi. Having a motorbike would definitely make getting around easier.
When you stay at The ShellSea Krabi I Luxury Beach Resort & Pool Villas, you'll be on the beach, within a 5-minute drive of Shell Fossil Beach and Gastropo Fossils The World Museum. This hotel is 5.2 mi (8.4 km) from Ao Nang Beach and 4.8 mi (7.7 km) from West Railay Beach. Pamper yourself with a visit to the spa, which offers massages and body treatments. You're sure to appreciate the recreational amenities, which include 2 outdoor swimming pools, a sauna, and a fitness center. This hotel also features complimentary wireless Internet access, concierge services, and babysitting (surcharge). Enjoy international cuisine at Cerulean, one of the hotel's 2 restaurants, or stay in and take advantage of the room service (during limited hours). Unwind at the end of the day with a drink at the bar/lounge or the poolside bar. Buffet breakfasts are available daily from 7:30 AM to 10:00 AM for a fee. Featured amenities include a computer station, dry cleaning/laundry services, and a 24-hour front desk. A roundtrip airport shuttle is provided for a surcharge (available 24 hours), and free self parking is available onsite. Treat yourself to a stay in one of the individually furnished guestrooms, featuring private pools and flat-screen televisions. Complimentary wired and wireless Internet access keeps you connected, and cable programming provides entertainment. Bathrooms with separate bathtubs and showers feature deep soaking bathtubs and rainfall showerheads. Conveniences include phones, as well as safes and desks.
GGuest User2025.04.28
It’s quite secluded which is why we picked it. It’s quiet and honestly a paradise. However if you want to do loads of stuff and activities you will need to get a taxi/grab/bolt everywhere, there is very little to do in walking distance and there are no paths to walk for the most part, so it really depends on what you are looking for. They have a small vehicle which goes to ao nang 4 times a day. Once in ao nang (20 mins away) you can get boats to Railay beach, or other islands. It’s busy and touristy in ao nang so the shellsea is a nice escape from this. 20 mins the other way is Krabi town which we preferred, with the mountain monument (highly recommend but only if you are fit!!). A grab/bolt here is about 180baht each way.
The hotel breakfast is lovely with coffees made to order. There is another restaurant which overlooks the beach and sea which is really nice too. The pool area overlooks the bay and is quiet and peaceful. Very well maintained and clean. There are lots of activities on at the hotel if you prefer to stay around the hotel such as Pilates, yoga, Muay Thai, kayaking, etc.
Staff are friendly and attentive.
Friendly Hotel Krabi offers top-notch services and amenities, ensuring guests experience utmost comfort.Remain linked during your visit by utilizing the complimentary internet access available.Experience the wonders of Krabi with ease by utilizing the services provided at shuttle. The hotel offers complimentary parking for guests who arrive with their own mode of transport.Reception services featuring luggage storage are available to cater to your requirements.Repeatedly enjoy your best-loved attire with the aid of the laundry service available at Friendly Hotel Krabi. During leisurely days and evenings, in-room amenities such as room service and daily housekeeping enable you to maximize your stay in the room. The hotel is completely smoke-free. Crafted for coziness, every guestroom provides an array of features, guaranteeing a tranquil night's sleep while maintaining the level of comfort. For a more enjoyable stay, select rooms at hotel are equipped with linen service, blackout curtains and air conditioning. At Friendly Hotel Krabi, a selection of rooms can be found that showcase unique design elements such as a balcony or terrace. For certain chosen rooms, guests can enjoy in-room amusement like television and cable TV as a part of their stay.Rest assured that your hydration needs will be met, as some guestrooms are equipped with a refrigerator, a coffee or tea maker, bottled water, instant coffee and instant tea.It is worth noting that certain guest bathrooms feature a hair dryer and toiletries for your convenience. Each morning at Friendly Hotel Krabi, a scrumptious, homemade breakfast kick-starts the day.During your visit, indulge in a range of delightful culinary choices at hotel to enhance your experience.Friendly Hotel Krabi provides a superb assortment of leisure amenities for guests to enjoy.Begin your holiday perfectly by taking a plunge into the swimming pool.
WWan Rashdan2025.01.15
1. **Warm Hospitality**: Many hotels in Krabi are commended for their friendly and welcoming staff who go out of their way to ensure that guests have a comfortable stay.
2. **Clean and Comfortable Accommodations**: Good reviews often mention well-maintained rooms and comfortable amenities that make for a pleasant stay.
3. **Great Location**: Proximity to beaches, restaurants, and tourist attractions is often highlighted in favorable reviews.
4. **Value for Money**: Many travelers appreciate hotels that offer good value, with reasonable prices for the quality of services and amenities provided.
5. **Local Recommendations**: Friendly and knowledgeable staff often provide excellent recommendations for local attractions, eateries, and activities, enhancing the overall experience for guests.
If ”Friendly Hotel Krabi” is a newly opened or less-publicized establishment, I recommend checking recent reviews on booking and review platforms to get the latest insights.
With a stay at Anyavee Chom By The Sea in Krabi (Sai Thai), you'll be within a 15-minute drive of Ao Nang Beach and Ao Nam Mao. This hotel is 5 mi (8 km) from Nopparat Thara Beach and 11.3 mi (18.1 km) from Khlong Muang Beach.
Enjoy recreation amenities such as an outdoor pool or take in the view from a garden. This hotel also features complimentary wireless internet access and a picnic area.
At Anyavee Chom By The Sea, enjoy a satisfying meal at the restaurant.
The front desk is staffed during limited hours. Free self parking is available onsite.
Make yourself at home in one of the 29 individually decorated guestrooms. Bathrooms with bathtubs or showers are provided. Conveniences include phones, as well as desks and separate sitting areas.
AAnonymous User2026.02.15
We stayed at the hotel for several days in early December.
We liked the hotel. The breakfasts were quite varied and always hot, which was a pleasant surprise as we have something to compare it to. The pool was nice.
The receptionist was very sweet.
Our room was small. We didn't have enough storage space in the room; the wardrobe only had a rail and a high shelf, which was inconvenient to use even for someone tall like me. Our clothes ended up piled on the floor inside the wardrobe. In the shower, there was only one small, steeply slanted shelf, making it impossible to place anything on it. We had to buy a plastic floor shelf for our toiletries. My suggestion to the owner is to address this issue.
Another downside was the poor cleaning. On a scale of five, it would be a three with a big minus. The floors still had hair on them, and the shower wasn't cleaned either. My suggestion to management is to improve cleaning standards. This also influences the overall impression of the hotel.
One more negative was the large number of plants with dried leaves. It was clear they weren't getting enough water. I constantly felt like watering them!
Despite some drawbacks, I really liked the hotel. We took a boat to Railay Beach. The beach near the hotel isn't suitable for swimming.
With a stay at Villa Cha-Cha Krabi Beachfront Resort in Krabi, you'll be on the beach, within a 10-minute drive of Ao Nang Beach and Ao Nam Mao. This 4-star hotel is 2.4 mi (3.9 km) from East Railay Beach and 5.2 mi (8.3 km) from Nopparat Thara Beach.
Pamper yourself with onsite massages or take in the view from a terrace and a garden. This hotel also features complimentary wireless Internet access, concierge services, and wedding services.
Satisfy your appetite for lunch or dinner at the hotel's restaurant, or stay in and take advantage of the room service (during limited hours). Relax with your favorite drink at the bar/lounge or the poolside bar. Buffet breakfasts are available daily from 7:00 AM to 11:00 AM for a fee.
Featured amenities include dry cleaning/laundry services, a 24-hour front desk, and multilingual staff. A roundtrip airport shuttle is provided for a surcharge (available 24 hours), and free self parking is available onsite.
Make yourself at home in one of the 110 air-conditioned rooms featuring refrigerators and flat-screen televisions. Complimentary wireless Internet access keeps you connected, and cable programming is available for your entertainment. Private bathrooms with showers feature rainfall showerheads and complimentary toiletries. Conveniences include phones, as well as safes and complimentary bottled water.
MMarlé South Africa2026.02.22
Really beautiful place right on the beach. Several pools. Nice restaurant and amazing breakfast buffet, even for me as a vegan. Our room was nothing special so we spent most of the time at the pool. Many chairs to lie on in the shade. A bit over priced for the Chinese new year holiday. But we really enjoyed it and the staff was very friendly and moved us to a new room after we complained about noisy neighbors. Check-out time is 11am which is a bit early to be honest. But you can still relax by the pool and facilities after checkout.
With a stay at Diamond Beach Resort in Krabi (Ao Nang), you'll be a 1-minute drive from Ao Nam Mao and 10 minutes from Ao Nang Landmark Night Market. This beach hotel is 3.6 mi (5.8 km) from Ao Nang Beach and 12.9 mi (20.8 km) from Khlong Muang Beach.Take advantage of recreation opportunities such as an outdoor pool or take in the view from a terrace and a garden. Additional amenities at this hotel include complimentary wireless internet access, tour/ticket assistance, and a picnic area. Getting to nearby attractions is a breeze with the area shuttle (surcharge) that operates within 1 kilometers.Take advantage of the hotel's room service.Featured amenities include complimentary wired internet access, a 24-hour front desk, and luggage storage. For a surcharge, guests may use a roundtrip airport shuttle (available on request) and a ferry terminal shuttle.Make yourself at home in one of the 43 air-conditioned rooms featuring refrigerators. Complimentary wireless internet access keeps you connected, and satellite programming is available for your entertainment. Private bathrooms with showers feature rainfall showerheads and complimentary toiletries. Conveniences include separate sitting areas and electric kettles, and housekeeping is provided once per stay.
MMoerzibigangsimajiong2025.11.09
The hotel environment is really nice, and the views are beautiful too. The only downside is that the bathroom is a bit basic. However, the ladies at the front desk were incredibly friendly and helpful. I'd definitely choose to stay here again next time I'm in Krabi.
With a stay at Railay Garden View Resort in Krabi (Railay Beach), you'll be within a 15-minute walk of West Railay Beach and East Railay. This beach hotel is within close proximity of Princess Lagoon and Phra Nang Cave.
Take in the views from a terrace and a garden and make use of amenities such as tour/ticket assistance.
At Railay Garden View Resort, enjoy a satisfying meal at the restaurant. Full breakfasts are available daily from 7:00 AM to 10:30 AM for a fee.
Make yourself at home in one of the 19 guestrooms. Rooms have private balconies. Bathrooms with showers are provided.
AAnonymous User2026.05.24
The accommodation is lovely and very beautiful. I didn't even have to carry my own luggage when I arrived, which was impressive. I saw it recommended in a review on the black app. It's a bit of a walk, but the view is stunning.
When you stay at Bhu Nga Thani Resort & Villas Railay in Krabi, you'll be on the boardwalk/promenade, within a 15-minute drive of Ao Nang Beach and West Railay Beach. This upscale hotel is 5.2 mi (8.4 km) from Nopparat Thara Beach and 11.5 mi (18.6 km) from Khlong Muang Beach.
Enjoy recreation amenities such as an outdoor pool or take in the view from a garden. Additional features at this Colonial hotel include complimentary wireless internet access, gift shops, and tour/ticket assistance.
Enjoy a satisfying meal at Bhu Nga Sari serving guests of Bhu Nga Thani Resort & Villas Railay. Buffet breakfasts are available daily from 7:30 AM to 10:30 AM for a fee.
Featured amenities include limo/town car service and luggage storage. For a surcharge, guests may use a roundtrip airport shuttle (available 24 hours) and a ferry terminal shuttle.
Make yourself at home in one of the 60 air-conditioned rooms featuring refrigerators and LCD televisions. Complimentary wireless internet access keeps you connected, and satellite programming is available for your entertainment. Bathrooms with separate bathtubs and showers feature deep soaking bathtubs and rainfall showerheads. Conveniences include safes and desks, and housekeeping is provided daily.
GGuest User2026.03.19
We had a very disappointing and disturbing experience during our stay at this hotel.
Unfortunately, money was stolen from our room. What makes the situation even more concerning is that not all of the cash was taken — exactly half of it was missing. This made it less immediately noticeable, but it was very clear to us that the amount had been deliberately reduced.
We always keep track of our belongings, and there is no doubt that the money was taken while we were out. This raises serious concerns about security and trust, especially in a place where guests expect their personal items to be safe.
We only discovered the issue later the same day, after we had already checked out of the hotel, which made the situation even more upsetting.
Because of this experience, we cannot recommend this hotel and strongly advise future guests to be extremely cautious with their valuables.
With a stay at Infinity Aonang Krabi Hotel, you'll be centrally located in Krabi, a 4-minute drive from West Railay Beach and 6 minutes from Ao Nang Beach. This upscale hotel is 2.8 mi (4.5 km) from Nopparat Thara Beach and 9.2 mi (14.9 km) from Khlong Muang Beach.
Be sure to enjoy recreational amenities, including an outdoor pool, an indoor pool, and a fitness center. This hotel also features complimentary wireless internet access, concierge services, and babysitting (surcharge). The complimentary beach shuttle makes getting to the surf and sand a breeze.
Satisfy your appetite with Thai cuisine at FIN Bar & Bistro, a restaurant where you can take in the pool view. Snacks are also available at the coffee shop/cafe. Relax with a refreshing drink from the poolside bar or one of the 2 bars/lounges. Buffet breakfasts are available daily from 6:30 AM to 10:30 AM for a fee.
Featured amenities include express check-in, dry cleaning/laundry services, and a 24-hour front desk. Planning an event in Krabi? This hotel has 2691 square feet (250 square meters) of space consisting of conference space and a meeting room. A roundtrip airport shuttle is provided for a surcharge (available 24 hours), and free self parking is available onsite.
Make yourself at home in one of the 71 guestrooms featuring minibars and Smart televisions. Your pillowtop bed comes with premium bedding. Complimentary wireless internet access keeps you connected, and satellite programming is available for your entertainment. Bathrooms feature showers with rainfall showerheads and complimentary toiletries.
RRUBAYET ANSARY2026.05.31
Modern amenities with good location, just only complain would be they do not provide Toothbrush. Other than that, it's a great hotel, breakfast a bit modest but good, felt like there's more of a local vibe here, staffs helpful but some of them do not speak English.
When you stay at Sand Sea Resort in Krabi, you'll be on the beach, just steps from West Railay Beach and 5 minutes by foot from East Railay Beach. This beach hotel is within close proximity of Phra Nang Cave and Princess Lagoon.
Treat yourself with massages, body treatments, and facials. You're sure to appreciate the recreational amenities, which include 2 outdoor swimming pools and a fitness center. This hotel also features complimentary wireless Internet access, concierge services, and babysitting (surcharge).
Grab a bite to eat at Sunset restaurant, a beachfront restaurant which features an ocean view. You can also stay in and take advantage of the room service (during limited hours). Quench your thirst with your favorite drink at the beach bar. Buffet breakfasts are available daily from 7 AM to 10 AM for a fee.
Featured amenities include a business center, complimentary newspapers in the lobby, and dry cleaning/laundry services. Planning an event in Krabi? This hotel has facilities measuring 215 square feet (20 square meters), including conference space. A roundtrip airport shuttle is provided for a surcharge (available 24 hours), and limited parking is available onsite.
Make yourself at home in one of the 123 air-conditioned rooms featuring refrigerators and minibars (stocked with some free items). Rooms have private balconies. Satellite programming and DVD players are provided for your entertainment, while complimentary wireless Internet access keeps you connected. Private bathrooms have complimentary toiletries and hair dryers.
GGuest User2026.06.01
I recently had the pleasure of staying at this resort, and I can confidently say it is the best place to stay in Krabi. Everything about the experience was absolutely outstanding.
The Service
The highlight of my stay was undoubtedly the service. If I could rate it 100/100%, I would! The staff went above and beyond to ensure every aspect of my visit was perfect. They are attentive, professional, and genuinely warm, making me feel welcomed and well-cared for from the moment I arrived until the moment I checked out.
The Experience
The resort itself is beautiful and perfectly situated. Whether you are looking for relaxation or a base to explore Krabi, this property provides the perfect atmosphere. The facilities were clean, well-maintained, and exceeded all my expectations.
Great
423 reviews
9.2/10
Price from
€ 49
per night
Check Availability
See All Hotels Near Fossil Shell Beach
Latest Reviews for Krabi Town hotels
See all
Read real traveler ratings & reviews to find your perfect stay.
9.4/10
Amazing
RRodrigoBHere's a short review in English based on your notes:
---
This hotel is beautiful and tranquil, set in a tropical environment with many open-air areas. You need to go outside to reach the reception, restaurant, or bathroom from your room. They have done a fantastic job of combining luxury with a natural, jungle-like setting—something I've never seen before. The staff is incredibly friendly and helpful. Breakfast is really good. If you're looking for a more exotic nature experience, this place is ideal. However, if you prefer a more standard/business stay, it might not be the best option.
GGuest UserWe stayed here for just one night while passing through — and that’s honestly the only downside, because we really liked it and would have happily stayed longer.
The staff are very polite and welcoming, and you can tell they genuinely care and pay attention to details. Everything is thoughtfully designed: comfortable, clean, and very pleasant.
The property consists of several villas arranged around a pool. The pool itself is great — easy access and very convenient to use.
The room doesn’t offer much in terms of cooking facilities, but everything else is perfectly arranged. The bed is very comfortable, with an excellent mattress.
Breakfast is served buffet-style, and the staff carefully maintain cleanliness and order.
It’s also a very quiet and peaceful place.
TTati_13They let me check in early, which I really appreciated. I got a spacious room with a terrace on the top floor, so the view was amazing! Great location. The ladies at the front desk were all very smiling and friendly. Housekeeping every day, clean towels, two bottles of water, coffee. The only downside is that my bed linen wasn't changed once during the whole week.
IItsnamthipA Perfect Birthday Stay at Pakasai Resort!
I stayed at Pakasai Resort in Ao Nang, Krabi for 2 nights (June 22–24) and couldn’t have asked for a more wonderful experience—especially for my birthday! I originally only hoped for a room upgrade, but the resort went far beyond my expectations and made my celebration truly unforgettable.
From the moment I arrived, the staff were incredibly warm and friendly. I was pleasantly surprised with a complimentary room upgrade, and the surprises didn’t stop there. On my birthday, I was greeted with a beautiful birthday cake, a thoughtful message arranged on the bed, and genuinely heartfelt service throughout the day.
I also booked dinner at GAIA, the resort’s own restaurant, and was treated to a free cocktail to celebrate. The atmosphere, service, and food were all excellent—it was the perfect birthday dinner.
The resort itself is cozy and peaceful, surrounded by lush greenery that makes you feel close to nature. The pool area is lovely and relaxing, and the entire resort has a calm, welcoming vibe.
Overall, I felt truly taken care of during my stay. I highly recommend Pakasai Resort to anyone visiting Ao Nang, especially if you're looking for a place that combines comfort, nature, and genuinely caring service. I’m already thinking about coming back!
KKaoroubaoI absolutely loved my stay at this beach resort in Krabi—it was absolutely perfect in every way. The scenery here is breathtakingly beautiful, with turquoise waters, golden sand, and stunning limestone cliffs all around. The beach itself is incredibly clean, well-maintained, and simply gorgeous; I couldn’t have asked for a nicer spot to relax by the ocean.
The best part by far is the resort’s swimming pool, which is actually the largest pool in Thailand. We spent so much time there and had the best time swimming, laughing, and enjoying the water—it was so much fun.
The rooms were lovely and comfortable, and the service was outstanding. The staff were kind, helpful, and attentive to every need.
Overall, everything was flawless. We had an incredible time in Thailand, and this resort made our trip even more wonderful. I can’t recommend it enough!
RRuairi Peter GoganGreat location. Older room, but good. Pool closes at 6pm which is way too early. Im hoping they reconsider at keep pool open until 10pm with tbe pool lights on. Put fans in the balcony.
GGuest UserGreat location, and the small bungalows and houses look quite nice. However, the front area near the beach, including the pool and restaurant, wasn't very well-maintained and was partly dirty. The pool water was cloudy and not very inviting, so I didn't use it. I had a 'new room,' which sounds good, but it wasn't. It was inadequately furnished – nowhere to put luggage, no chair... and it was very unclean. It seemed nothing had been cleaned after construction, as protective plastic was still stuck everywhere. The wardrobe was just a rail where the kettle and other items were also placed. At least they quickly brought me more hangers when I asked. The only really good thing was the new sun loungers on the balcony. My room wasn't cleaned, and when I inquired, I was told I had to leave my room key at reception for that. Seriously? I've never encountered that before, and it would have been helpful if they had informed me. Breakfast was very basic, and I didn't like the coffee. However, the à la carte dinner was delicious.
GGuest UserCheck in was a breeze with luggage handlers helping carry your luggage from the pier to the hotel. The reception girls are really lovely and helpful with whatever request you might have(like booking boats to your next destination), just remember to say please and thank you(kohp khun ka/krap). The hotel is the last one on the pier side bay, therefore is really quiet, even now in high season. The down low is that you have to walk 20minutes to restaurants and bars on 30+ degree heat + high humity,so expect to arrive sweating both ways. The hotel itself is probably 40/50 years old and seems that never been renovated, the inside of the rooms need freshing up,paint etc...an overall renovation of the whole building. Although the rooms were clean, aircon was good and our room with the pool access(1 of 3) had great views from the bay. Pool was also clean and it was at a good temperature. If you are here for just a couple of days it is fine. Breakfast is basic but they have an egg station, so you can order your eggs however you prefer. And the black coffee was great too(better than other hotels we stayed in Bangkok/Krabi). The hotel staff were very kind to supply my wife with Flying Rabbit(a local thai version of gaviscon/diarrhoea medicine) which helped a mild food poisoning combined with charcoal tablets. Moreover, the hotel has a little private beach with sun lounges at the very end of the bay, perfect for chilling when you don't have any boat trips booked for the morning. Be aware that it becomes shady after around 3pm because its so close to the mountain. Also there were monkeys signs on your doors to keep them lock to prevent curious monkeys of rummaging through your stuff but we haven't seen any during our 3 night stay. Would I stay at this hotel again? Probably not unless completely renovated:, too far from the restaurants and bars and very old/tired. Make sure you use some walking shoes when going out because you definitely gonna hit that 10000 steps mark.
HH RanatungaThis hotel stay was very nice. The pool view is stunning
The hotel owner is very helpful and friendly. She even upgraded our room without extra cost .
She even organised someone to pick us up and carry our bags from the pear and from hotel to pear at check-in and check out . She even keeps our bags in a place near to pear for us to pick up in the afternoon for our ferry trip.
Staff is very friendly too.
We really enjoyed our two days stay and definitely recommend this hotel stay
Will come back again with my family
See view villa was the one we stayed it was the best
GGuest UserThis hotel is amazing!
It used to be a temple so it has a fantastic Thai architecture.
The room and bathroom were really big and spacious. The staff was friendly and the housekeeping is daily and dedicated. The aircon worked well, the bed was comfortable and there's plenty of furniture in the rooms. The swimming pool is big and in good condition.
The hotel is right in front of the beach but not in the central Ao Nang area.
The wifi was very weak during the whole stay.
How much is a hotel near Fossil Shell Beach Krabi (Susan Hoi) per night?
According to Trip.com, the average price for a one-night stay at a hotel near Fossil Shell Beach Krabi (Susan Hoi) in Krabi Town is € 72. Prices can change frequently, so this rate is just an estimate.
What’s the average price of hotels near Fossil Shell Beach Krabi (Susan Hoi) this weekend?
According to Trip.com, the average price for a one-night weekend stay at a hotel near Fossil Shell Beach Krabi (Susan Hoi) in Krabi Town is around € 185. Keep in mind that prices can vary frequently, so this rate is just an estimate.
What are the best hotels to stay near Fossil Shell Beach Krabi (Susan Hoi)?